On this page 9
Key takeaways
- Monthly fee drag = trades per month × average trade size (% of capital) × fee per trade. The calculator's defaults (60 trades, 10%, 0.1%) cost 0.6% of capital a month.
- Break-even capital = subscription ÷ (gross monthly return − fee drag). Below it, the plan loses money even if the strategy works.
- At 2% gross a month, a $29 plan needs about $2,071 to break even; at 1%, about $7,250. Small accounts rarely justify paid tiers.
- Free plans, exchange-native bots and open-source software usually win until your capital is several thousand dollars.
Will a paid bot pay for itself?
Fees · subscription · break-evenA "trade" here is one order (buy or sell). Exchange fees apply on top of the bot subscription.
Most bot marketing talks about returns. This trading bot ROI calculator focuses on the part you can know in advance: costs. A subscription is a fixed monthly bill, and trading fees grow with every order the bot places. Put both next to a realistic return and you find out quickly whether a paid plan makes sense for your balance. If it does not, our guide to free AI crypto trading bots lists the alternatives.
What to enter
- Capital the bot trades: only the money allocated to the bot, not your whole portfolio.
- Subscription: the monthly price of your plan. Use the annual-billing monthly equivalent if you pay yearly.
- Gross monthly return before fees: your assumption for what the strategy makes before any costs. Try several values, including zero and negative.
- Trades per month: count each buy or sell order as one trade. A grid bot doing 30 round trips a month places 60 orders.
- Average trade size: the typical order as a percentage of the bot's capital.
- Fee per trade: your exchange's fee for that order type, for example 0.05% on Pionex spot or 0.1% at many exchanges' base tier.
- Months: how long to compound.
Fee drag: the cost you do not see
Trading fees are charged on the order value, but what matters is how much of your capital they take each month. That is the fee drag:
fee drag (% of capital per month) = trades per month × trade size % × fee %
example: 60 × 10% × 0.1% = 0.6% per month Another way to see it: 60 orders each worth 10% of capital means your capital turns over six times a month, and you pay the fee on all of it. Over a year, 0.6% a month is about 7.2% of capital before compounding. Halve the fee to 0.05% and the drag halves. Halve the number of trades and it halves again. For high-frequency strategies like dense grids, fee tier is often the single biggest lever. The grid bot profit calculator shows the same effect per grid.
The break-even capital formula
A subscription is a fixed cost, so it hurts small accounts most. The capital at which the strategy's profit after trading fees exactly pays the subscription is:
break-even capital = subscription ÷ (gross monthly return − fee drag)
example: $29 ÷ (3% − 0.6%) = $29 ÷ 0.024 ≈ $1,208 Below that capital, you lose money even if the strategy performs as you hoped. Above it, the subscription becomes a smaller and smaller share of the profit. If the gross return is at or below the fee drag, the denominator is zero or negative and the answer is "never": the strategy loses money on fees alone.
Break-even examples with real subscription prices
The table uses monthly list prices checked on official pricing pages in October 2026 and the default fee drag of 0.6% a month. Returns are assumptions for illustration; no bot guarantees any of them.
Break-even capital at 0.6% monthly fee drag (our own calculation)
| Plan | Price/mo | At 1% gross | At 2% gross | At 3% gross |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| WunderTrading Basicwundertrading.com ↗ | $19 | $4,750 | $1,357 | $792 |
| 3Commas Starter3commas.io ↗ | $20 | $5,000 | $1,429 | $833 |
| Stoic AI Starterstoic.ai ↗ | $24 | $6,000 | $1,714 | $1,000 |
| Bitsgap Basicbitsgap.com ↗ | $29 | $7,250 | $2,071 | $1,208 |
| Cryptohopper Explorercryptohopper.com ↗ | $29 | $7,250 | $2,071 | $1,208 |
| Bitsgap Advancedbitsgap.com ↗ | $69 | $17,250 | $4,929 | $2,875 |
| Cryptohopper Herocryptohopper.com ↗ | $129 | $32,250 | $9,214 | $5,375 |
Notice how sensitive the result is to the return assumption. Going from 3% to 1% a month multiplies the capital you need by six. Since nobody can promise 3% a month, the 1% column is the safer planning number.
Stoic's balance-based pricing
Stoic AI prices by balance rather than bot count. Starter ($24/mo or $149/yr) covers balances up to $2,500, Plus ($39/mo) up to $5,000 and Pro ($66/mo) up to $10,000. Above $10,000 you pay Pro plus 5% a year on the excess. At $20,000 that is $66 + $41.67 = about $107.67 a month, or 0.54% of capital monthly. At $50,000 it is about $232.67 a month, 0.47%. So Stoic's cost behaves less like a fixed subscription and more like a management fee once balances grow. Enter it as a subscription at your balance level. More in our Stoic AI review.
A year of costs on three account sizes
Here is the calculator's compounding output for 12 months at a 2% gross monthly return and the default 0.6% fee drag, with no subscription (a free plan), $20/mo and $29/mo.
12-month net profit at 2% gross per month, 0.6% fee drag (our own calculation)
| Capital | Free plan | $20/mo plan | $29/mo plan | Trading fees paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $1,000 | +$181.56 | −$77.81 | −$194.53 | $66–$78 |
| $3,000 | +$544.68 | +$285.31 | +$168.59 | $221–$233 |
| $10,000 | +$1,815.59 | +$1,556.22 | +$1,439.50 | $766–$778 |
The $1,000 account is the lesson. The same strategy that earns $182 on a free plan loses $195 on a $29 plan. On $10,000 the subscription barely matters. Trading fees, meanwhile, scale with capital at every size, which is why fee tier and trade count deserve as much attention as the plan price.
When free plans win
For most accounts under a few thousand dollars, a free option beats a paid tier on pure maths. The main choices as of October 2026:
| Option | What is free | The catch |
|---|---|---|
| Pionexpionex.com ↗ | All built-in bots; 0.05% spot fee | Funds held on Pionex (custodial) |
| Bitsgap Freebitsgap.com ↗ | 3 COMBO bots on EVEDEX, 20 demo bots | Limited to one venue for live bots |
| WunderTrading Freewundertrading.com ↗ | Lifetime free plan after a 7-day Pro trial | Feature and bot limits |
| Coinrule Startercoinrule.com ↗ | 2 live rules, 1 exchange, $3k/mo volume | Not available to EU/EEA residents |
| Freqtradefreqtrade.io ↗ | Open-source software (GPL-3.0) | You run the server and write the code |
Paid plans start to make sense when three things are true: your capital is well above the break-even level at a conservative return, you need a feature the free tier lacks (more exchanges, futures, more bots), and you have run the strategy in demo mode long enough to trust your return estimate. Our free AI crypto trading bots guide covers the limits of each free plan in detail, and the best AI crypto trading bots ranking compares the paid tiers.
Bot or no bot, start with a venue you can check
If the numbers say a paid bot is not worth it yet, buying and holding is a legitimate plan. CEX.IO has operated since 2013, is a FinCEN-registered MSB with money transmitter licences in 39 US states plus DC and is FCA-registered in the UK. It does not offer bots itself.
Registrations checked October 2026 on the company's legal pages. Availability depends on your country; crypto is high-risk.
- Since 2013One of the longest-running crypto exchanges still operating
source - 39 US states + DCFinCEN-registered MSB with state money transmitter licences (NMLS 1804170)
source - FCA-registeredUK cryptoasset business under the MLRs, FRN 1007192
source - PCI DSS Level 1Card-payment security standard, 2026 certificate published
source
What return should you enter?
Be conservative. Vendor return figures, such as Bitsgap's "11% average 30-day grid return", are marketing claims that cannot be independently verified. The most transparent live-money test of AI traders we know of, Alpha Arena, saw only 6 of 32 model runs finish positive in Season 1.5. The US CFTC has warned that AI will not turn trading bots into money machines and that promises of huge or guaranteed returns are a hallmark of fraud.
A sensible approach: run the calculator at 0%, 1% and your optimistic case, and only commit if the plan is acceptable in the first two. Remember that the calculator applies the same return every month. Real strategies have losing streaks, and a −5% month early on hurts more than the average suggests. Our evidence review, do AI crypto trading bots work?, goes deeper. Nothing on this page is financial advice.
Frequently asked questions
How do I calculate the ROI of a trading bot?
Start from the gross return the strategy makes, subtract trading fees (trades × trade size × fee rate) and the subscription, and divide what is left by your capital. The calculator does this month by month and compounds it, so a fee drag that looks small per month shows its full effect over a year.
How much money do I need for a paid trading bot to be worth it?
Divide the monthly subscription by your expected monthly return after trading fees. At 3% gross and 0.6% fee drag, a $29 plan needs about $1,208 just to break even, and a $129 plan about $5,375. At a more modest 1% gross, the same plans need $7,250 and $32,250.
Is this an AI trading bot profit calculator?
It works for any automated strategy, AI or not, because costs work the same way. The return you enter is your assumption. No vendor's return claims for AI bots can be independently verified, so test with a range of returns, including zero and negative months.
Why does the calculator say "Never" for break-even capital?
Because your trading fees already equal or exceed the gross return. In that case no amount of capital fixes it: the strategy loses money before the subscription. Reduce the number of trades, use a lower-fee venue or maker orders, or reconsider the strategy.
Can I use it as a crypto ROI calculator for holding?
Set trades per month and subscription to zero and it becomes a simple compound-return calculator. For holding with monthly top-ups, the compound ROI calculator on our tools hub is a better fit, and the DCA calculator models buying on a schedule.
Are annual plans worth it?
Only once you know the bot works for you. Annual billing lowers the monthly cost (for example 3Commas Starter drops from $20 to $15 a month and Bitsgap Basic from $29 to $23), which lowers break-even capital by a fifth to a quarter. But you pay up front, and refunds are limited on several platforms.
Keep reading
Sources and fact-check dates
We link to primary sources wherever possible. Dates show when the page was published or when we last checked it.
- 3Commas pricing · checked 2026-10-21
- Bitsgap pricing · checked 2026-10-21
- Cryptohopper pricing · checked 2026-10-21
- Stoic AI plans and balance limits · checked 2026-10-21
- WunderTrading pricing · checked 2026-10-21
- Pionex fee schedule · checked 2026-10-21
- Alpha Arena leaderboard (Season 1.5) · checked 2026-10-21
- CFTC advisory: AI Won't Turn Trading Bots into Money Machines · checked 2026-10-21